Empire State Library Network (ESLN)

ADA Title II WCAG Compliance Position Statement & FAQ

To best serve the library users of New York, it is important for all web and mobile app services offered by New York’s public, private, and academic libraries to be accessible to people with disabilities.

One way to ensure websites and mobile apps are accessible is to ensure they meet the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (“WCAG”).

This accessibility is so important that it is enforced by the United States Department of Justice and the New York State Division of Human Rights under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”) and the Human Rights Law.

For public institutions, the federal government has identified a precise standard that websites and mobile apps must meet with limited exceptions: WCAG version 2.1, level AA. Private institutions have a bit more flexibility but still must aim for accessibility.

The deadlines for public institutions—including public libraries, public schools, and public universities—to be WCAG compliant are April 26, 2027, and April 26, 2028.

Public institutions serving populations with over 50,000 people have the 2027 deadline. Public institutions serving smaller populations have until 2028.

In anticipation of these deadlines, and to support awareness and use of WCAG generally, ESLN has been providing materials and training to its members and institutions served by its members:

  • Capital District Library Council (CDLC)

  • Central New York Library Resources Council (CLRC)

  • Long Island Library Resources Council (LILRC)

  • METRO (Metropolitan New York Library Council)

  • Northern New York Library Network (NNYLN)

  • Rochester Regional Library Council (RRLC)

  • South Central Regional Library Council (SCRLC)

  • Southeastern New York Library Resources Council (SENYLRC)

  • Western New York Library Resources Council (WNYLRC)

Public institutions must ensure that their own e-resources comply as well as those they provide through a third party. For example, if a public library uses a cooperative library system to provide its website, the website must comply with ADA Title II, even if the cooperative library system’s other services do not.

This has raised a few questions for ESLN:

  1. Is ESLN a “public entity” under ADA Title II?

  2. Do all ESLN services have to be WCAG compliant by April 26, 2027?

  3. Is ESLN a “third party” to public institutions that must follow Title II?

  4. What are ESLN’s obligations for web and mobile app accessibility?

It is important for ESLN members and those they serve to have clarity on these questions, so here are the answers:

  1. Is ESLN a “public entity” under ADA Title II?

No, ESLN is not a “public entity” under Title II. This means that ESLN does not have a statutory obligation to offer WCAG-compliant services by a certain deadline.

  1. Do all ESLN services have to be WCAG compliant by April 26, 2027?

No. ESLN services that are generally available to the public but not provided to public entities under a formal arrangement (such as a contract, fee for service, or as part of a sub-award on a grant) do not have to be WCAG compliant by a certain deadline. That said, for generally available resources such as New York Heritage, ESLN strives for compliance anyway.

  1. Is ESLN a “third party” to public institutions that must follow Title II?

Yes. This means that ESLN services provided to public institutions under a formal arrangement must be compliant with WCAG 2.1 Level AA by the deadline corresponding to the size of the largest public institution using the services, in order for them to continue doing so. An example of this is Overdrive for resource sharing, which ESLN has confirmed meets the WCAG 2.1 AA standard.

  1. What are ESLN’s obligations for web and mobile app accessibility?

ESLN has accessibility obligations under ADA Title III (not Title II) and the New York State Human Rights Law. The difference is that while public institutions have a defined deadline and a required standard (WCAG 2.1 Level AA), ESLN and other private entities have more flexibility. This does not lessen their obligations but gives them broader ways to meet them.

The bottom line is that ESLN and its member organizations have an obligation to offer library and library-supporting services that are accessible to those with disabilities, to the greatest extent possible. While this involves compliance with WCAG 2.1 Level AA when services are offered to public institutions, it also involves careful consideration of ESLN offerings and ESLN’s commitment to accessibility at all times. To that end, ESLN may use the following statement on accessibility.

ESLN invites questions on the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) and other standards to ensure ESLN resources are accessible.

For the next three years, while public institutions address their compliance obligations under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act, ESLN will maintain a list of services offered with links to WCAG compliance assurance or information relevant to Title II compliance. This list will include language suitable for explaining that the resource is external to a public institution (and might not be WCAG compliant) and when it is provided as a WCAG-compliant service.

  1. Is ESLN obligated to update pre-existing content on ESLN resources to be WCAG 2.1 Level AA compliant?

No, but we are committed to ongoing improvement. Just like public institutions, ESLN will be using an ongoing process to triage and remediate web and mobile app services that are not readily accessible for those with disabilities.

  1. Is ESLN obligated to update pre-existing content on ESLN resources provided by public entities who must follow Title II?

No, although we are always striving to make sure ESLN-provided content is accessible.

  1. Who do I contact with questions related to ESLN services and WCAG 2.1 Level AA compliance?

If you discover a concern related to ESLN resources and accessibility, please notify:

Ask Us 24/7:

Caitlin Kenney

ckenney@wnylrc.org

716-633-0705 ext. 115

Ask the Archivist:

Tim Spindler

tspindler@lilrc.org

631-675-1570 x2000

Ask the Lawyer

Caitlin Kenney

ckenney@wnylrc.org

716-633-0705 ext. 115

Empire ADC:

Jennifer Palmentiero

jennifer@senylrc.org
845-883-9065 ext. 114

ESLN Academic Institutional Repository:

Ryan Hughes

rhughes@rrlc.org

585-206-2977

ESLN Academic Overdrive:

Meg Backus

meg@nnyln.org

315-265-1119 ext. 1

ESLN Candid:

Meg Backus

meg@nnyln.org

315-265-1119 ext. 1

ESLN website:

Zack Spalding

spalding@senylrc.org

(845) 883-9065 x111

New York Heritage:

Ryan Hughes

rhughes@rrlc.org

585-206-2977

NYS Historic Newspapers:

Chuck Henry

chuckh@nnyln.org

315-265-1119 Ext 3